5 Timeless Beauty in Shakespeares Summers Day captures the essence of eternal love and admiration found in nature.
Critical Analysis of the poem “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s Day”
Table of Contents
Introduction:
“Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” is a beautiful sonnet by William Shakespeare. In this poem, the speaker wonders whether he should compare his beloved to a lovely summer day. Instead of doing so, he praises his beloved’s beauty, which surpasses that of a summer day. The poem highlights the impermanence of summer and contrasts it with the eternal beauty of his friend. Ultimately, the speaker declares that his beloved’s loveliness will endure forever through the lines of this very poem.
Publication:
The poem was likely written in the 1590s, though it was not published until 1609. This poem is part of a group of poems called the “Fair Youth” sequence.
Summary:
In this poem, the speaker starts by asking the question: “Should I compare you to a summer’s day?” Then, for most of the poem, the speaker talks about the ways in which the person is different and better than a summer day.
In the second line, the speaker says that the person is more beautiful and calm than a summer’s day. Summer can be too rough, with strong winds, and the sun can be too hot or sometimes too dim. Also, summer doesn’t last very long—it quickly changes into autumn, and things start to fade away.
But the person in the poem is not like that. Their beauty will never fade and will stay forever. In the last part, the speaker explains how this is possible. The person’s beauty will last forever because it is written down in this poem. As long as people are alive to read it, the beauty will never die.
Analysis:
This sonnet is one of the most famous poems written by Shakespeare. It might even be the most famous short poem in English. Only some of Shakespeare’s other famous lines, like “To be or not to be” and “Romeo, Romeo, where are you, Romeo?” are better known. While this poem may not be the very best or most interesting of his sonnets, its simple and lovely way of praising the beloved has made it unforgettable.
At first glance, the poem seems to simply praise the beauty of the person it’s talking about. Summer can be too windy or too hot, but the beloved is always gentle and calm. Summer is compared to the “eye of heaven,” which is the sun, with its “golden” brightness. The words and pictures in the poem are easy to understand, like “the darling buds of May,” which change into the “eternal summer” that the speaker promises to the beloved. The language is clear and not too fancy, with almost every line ending with a pause, as if each one is a separate thought.
Sonnet 18 is also different from the 17 sonnets before it. In those, the speaker urged the young man to have children to keep his beauty alive. But in this sonnet, the speaker realizes that the young man might not need children at all to stay beautiful forever. Instead, his beauty can live through the poem itself. This poem, or “rhyme,” is the first attempt by the speaker to save the young man’s beauty for the future.
A key idea in this sonnet (and many others in the sequence) is that the speaker’s poem can outlast time and keep the beloved’s beauty alive for generations to come. The young man’s “eternal summer” will never fade because the poem will last as long as people are alive to read it. In the last lines, the speaker says that as long as people breathe and see, the poem will live on, keeping the young man’s beauty alive forever.
Themes:
- Art and Morality: Sonnet 18 is a love poem where the speaker tries to compare his beloved to a summer’s day or the sun, but realizes these comparisons don’t work because summer’s days suggest aging and death. The beloved’s beauty is eternal, like the poem itself. The speaker argues that the poem will keep the beloved’s beauty alive forever. This means that poetry has the power to make beauty last forever, unlike anything in the natural world, which fades with time. The poem honors both the beloved and the power of poetry to give eternal life.
- The Shortness of Youth and Beauty: The poem talks about how a person’s good looks and youth don’t last forever. Just like summer turns to fall, people get older, and their beauty fades. The poem reminds us that beautiful things in life are often temporary and don’t stay the same forever.
- The Forever-Lasting Poetry: The writer hopes that this poem will keep the person beautiful forever. Even if the person grows old or passes away, the poem will always remember their beauty. This means that poetry can make someone’s beauty last forever, even when time changes everything else.
- The Strength of Love: The poem shows how love can inspire people to do wonderful things, like writing poems. Love makes the writer want to praise and celebrate the person he loves. It shows that love can be very powerful and can make people express their feelings in special ways, like through poetry.
- Shakespeare’s Own Talent: Some people think the poem isn’t just about the person or the summer day. They believe it’s also about how talented Shakespeare is at writing. The poem shows Shakespeare’s creative power and how he can make something beautiful and lasting with his words, celebrating his own skills as a poet.
Context:
Procreation sonnet: The sonnet is called Procreation sonnet. A procreation sonnet is one of Shakespeare’s sonnets that encourage a young man to marry and have children. These sonnets suggest that the child will be a copy of the young man, ensuring his legacy through future generations. To become internal the poet’s friend do not need children, his poem is enough to immortal him.
Imagery:
- Golden Sun: The sun is described as having a “golden complexion,” evoking warmth and brightness.
- Darling Buds of May: Spring flowers, symbolizing new life and beauty.
- Eternal Summer: The beloved’s beauty is everlasting, unlike the fleeting season of summer.
- Comfortable Gaze: Looking at the beloved is always pleasant, unlike the discomfort of a hot summer day.
- Tactile imagery: refers to vivid descriptions that evoke the sense of touch. When a writer uses tactile imagery, they create mental pictures related to texture, temperature, pressure, or physical sensations. For example, “Sometime too hot the eye of heaven shines”
Tone:
The tone of the poem oscillates between pessimism and optimism. On the one hand, the poet talks about how nothing is permanent –how the weather changes, how the earth goes through various seasons one after the other, and how the human body must age and die. On the other hand, the poet also asserts the immortality of art. Art is, for Shakespeare, eternal. He knows that long after he is gone, his poetry will continue to be read and appreciated.
Setting:
The setting of the poem is interpreted as being Renaissance London.
Literary Terms:
Alliteration:
Alliteration is the repetition of consonant sounds in the beginning (or, stressed syllables) of nearby words.
Ex: In the line “So long lives this” long lives is alliteration.
Anaphora:
Anaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of each line of a poem, speech.
Ex: So long as men can breathe or eyes can see,
So long lives this, and this gives life to thee.
In these two lines the phrase ‘so long’ is repeated again is called anaphora.
End-Stopped Line
An end-stopped line is a line of verse that ends with a punctuation.
Ex: Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?
Thou art more lovely and more temperate:
In these two lines two punctuations(?, 🙂 are used.
Euphony:
Euphony is the combining of words that sound pleasant together or are easy to pronounce, usually because they contain lots of consonants with soft or subdued sounds (like L, M, N, and R) instead of consonants with harsh, harsh sounds (like T, P, and K). It is called cocophony.
Ex: So long as men can breathe or eyes can see,
So long lives this, and this gives life to thee.
In these two sentences ‘l’ sound is euphony.
Aporia:
Aporia is a rhetorical device in which a speaker expresses uncertainty or doubt—often pretended uncertainty or doubt—about something, usually as a way of proving a point.
Ex: Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?
In this sentence the poet asks question if he shall compare his friend with summer’s day. He says that he cannot compare with summer’s day with his friend.
Diacope:
Diacope is a figure of speech in which a word or phrase is repeated with a small number of intervening words.
Ex: So long lives this, and this gives life to thee.
In this line two words ‘this’ is repeated again in the sentence within a short interval of words.
Personification:
Personification is the attribution of human qualities to non-human things.
Ex: Nor shall death brag thou wander’st in his shade,
In this line death is compared with a living being who shows brag.
Juxtaposition:
Juxtaposition occurs when an author places two things side by side as a way of highlighting their differences.
Ex: Sometime too hot the eye of heaven shines,
And often is his gold complexion dimm’d;
Here two contradictory ideas of eye of heaven sometimes shines and sometimes dimm’d is referred as juxtaposition.
Difference between Juxtaposition, Antithesis, and Oxymoron:
Note: Juxtaposition: It refers to placing two elements side by side to highlight their differences or similarities. This can apply to sentences, phrases. Ex: “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times”.
Antithesis: This involves contrasting two ideas within a balanced sentence structure. It emphasizes the stark contrast between two opposing concepts. Ex: “No pain, no gain.”
Oxymoron: It combines two contradictory or opposing words to create a paradoxical effect, typically within a phrase. Ex: “Open secret”.
Antanaclasis:
Antanaclasis is a figure of speech in which a word or phrase is repeated within a sentence, but the word or phrase means something different each time it appears. For example,
And every fair from fair sometime declines.
The first ‘fair’ is fair full things and second fair is nature.
Metaphor:
Metaphor is two implicit comparison between two odd things.
The metaphor in the poem “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” by William Shakespeare is “the eye of heaven.” Here, Shakespeare compares the sun to an eye, implying that it watches over the earth like a vigilant eye watches over something.
Hyperbole:
Hyperbole is a figure of speech where exaggeration is used for emphasis or effect.
The hyperbole in Shakespeare’s “Sonnet 18” is found in the line “Nor shall death brag thou wander’st in his shade.” Here, Shakespeare exaggerates the idea that the beloved will never truly die or be overshadowed by death.
Litotes:
Litotes is a figure of speech where a negative word is used to express something positive. It’s like saying “not bad” to mean “good”.
Ex: Nor shall death brag thou wander’st in his shade.
In this line ‘nor brag’ means ‘belittle’.
Form:
The poem follows iambic pentameter and a regular pattern of rhyming words known as an ABAB rhyme scheme. This means that the first and third lines rhyme with each other, as do the second and fourth lines. However, what makes this sonnet interesting is the twist! Instead of changing the argument around line 9 (as is typical in sonnets), Shakespeare waits until the last two lines (the couplet) to reveal the main idea again.
In “Sonnet 18,” the last two lines are very important because they change the poem a little bit. This change is called the volta. Usually, in this type of poem, the change happens earlier, but in “Sonnet 18,” it happens later. This makes it a little different and special.
Meter:
Shakespeare wrote “Sonnet 18” using a rhythm called iambic pentameter. This rhythm is like a heartbeat in poetry, where each line has ten syllables that follow a soft-strong pattern. It sounds natural, similar to how people talk. The poem flows smoothly most of the time, but sometimes there are changes. For example, in line 3, Shakespeare starts with a “spondee,” which means two stressed syllables together: “Rough winds.” This breaks the usual pattern of five stresses per line and makes the rhythm stand out.
Rhyme Scheme:
“Sonnet 18” follows the traditional rhyme scheme of the Shakespearean sonnet:
ABABCDCDEFEFGG
The poem also contains a few significant instances of internal rhyme—for example, the slant rhyme between “line” and “time” in line 12. In “Sonnet 18” by William Shakespeare, the two words that express slant rhyme are “date” and “state”.
Style:
Style is what makes a writer or poet unique. It’s like their special way of writing that shows their voice, thoughts, and feelings. Every writer has a different style, which makes their work stand out. It’s the way they choose their words, how they put sentences together, and the way they express their ideas. All of this creates a certain mood or feeling in the writing.
When we talk about style in literature, we also mean the use of figures of speech like metaphors, similes, and alliterations, which help to make the writing more interesting. Style helps readers to see the writer’s personality and the way they think.
William Shakespeare had a very famous style, especially in his sonnets. His sonnets were usually made up of three parts called quatrains, followed by a final two-line couplet. This style helped him develop his ideas smoothly and come to a strong conclusion at the end. People all around the world admire Shakespeare for his way of writing, which is often seen as the best example of great poetry and drama. Shakespeare’s works are known for their deep meanings and beautiful language, though they can be a bit tricky to understand because of the way he played with words and sentence structures.
In simple terms, style is what makes every writer’s work special, and Shakespeare’s style is one that many consider a shining example in the world of literature.
Stylistic Analysis:
When writers write, they want to share their thoughts and ideas. But they also want to show how words can create meaning and make readers think or feel something. Stylistic analysis is a way to look closely at the style of writing. It helps us understand how writers use words to express their ideas and how readers find meaning in those words.
Stylistic analysis is done in a clear and organized way. It uses facts and information to explain a writer’s style. This method is more scientific and uses special words and terms from the study of language, called linguistics. It helps us understand why writers choose certain words and how those choices make their writing special.
Features of Stylistic Analysis:
1. Lexico-Syntax Features:
This is about how words (lexis) and sentence structures (syntax) are used in writing. Words and sentences are put together in different ways to share ideas. Writers may use special patterns like repeating words, leaving out words, or even changing the order of words. They also use old-fashioned words or figurative language like metaphors, similes, and onomatopoeia. When this is done in poetry, it makes the poem sound more natural and helps to emphasize the meaning.
2. Graphological Features:
This focuses on how words look on the page. It includes things like spelling, punctuation, size, and the shape of the words. These are important in understanding poems, especially ones like sonnets. The way the text is set up can help readers pay attention to the poem’s message. The look of the poem can even help strengthen the meaning of the words. When used in poetry, these visual details help give a deeper meaning to the poem by the way they are arranged.
3. Phonological Features:
These are all about the sounds of words. It studies how speech sounds are used in poetry. The way sounds are put together helps people enjoy and understand the poem better. Poetry often plays with sounds to make the poem more powerful. It shows how words are spoken and how those sounds add meaning to the poem.
Stylistics: Understanding the Beauty of Writing
Stylistics is all about looking at the special tools and words that writers use to make their stories and poems beautiful and meaningful. It helps us see how language can be used in unique ways to create feelings and effects in a piece of writing (Verdonk, 2002).
One famous writer, William Shakespeare, used many techniques to create amazing art with his words. In his poem Sonnet 18, he talks about the beauty and love of someone special. He also thinks about how life changes and doesn’t last forever. Shakespeare believes that through his timeless poems, like this sonnet, we can feel a sense of forever, even after people are gone.
Historical Background:
The poem Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day? by William Shakespeare was written during a time called the Renaissance, which was a period of change in art and literature. This was in the 16th century, about 400 years ago. During the Renaissance, writers and artists were influenced by ideas from Ancient Greece and Rome. They studied works by famous writers like Aristotle and Horace, and many writers wanted to copy or even improve on these classics.
Back then, writers often dedicated their poems or books to important people or even to God, which made their work seem more special. They would also sometimes put their picture or name on their work, which made them more respected. The best writers were called “poet laureates” and were honored with a crown made of leaves called a laurel wreath, just like the great poets of Ancient Rome.
Shakespeare lived during this exciting time and is considered one of the greatest writers ever. He wrote many different kinds of poems and plays, including sonnets. A sonnet is a special type of poem with 14 lines, and it was very popular during the Renaissance. This type of poem often talked about love, especially love that wasn’t returned or a person who seemed impossible to reach. The sonnet form was started by an Italian poet named Francesco Petrarca (Petrarch), and many writers like Shakespeare followed his style.
In Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?, Shakespeare praises someone’s beauty and says that it will last forever through his poem. This idea of using poetry to keep someone’s beauty alive was important during the Renaissance because people believed that great writing could stand the test of time. Shakespeare’s sonnet became very famous, and it’s still loved by many people today, showing that his words really have lasted for centuries.
Readers find that 5 Timeless Beauty in Shakespeares Summers Day eloquently expresses the power of poetry to immortalize beauty.
Literary Background:
“Sonnet 18” was probably written in the 1590s, during a time when sonnets were becoming very popular in England. The sonnet form started to appear in English poetry in the 1530s and 1540s when poets like Thomas Wyatt began translating poems from an Italian poet named Francesco Petrarch. Over the years, many poets, especially those from wealthy families, used sonnets to write about their secret loves and impress people at court.
William Shakespeare, who came from a common background, looked at this popular form with some doubt. He questioned its usual themes and tried to find new ways to use it for himself. Traditionally, sonnets were often about a man loving an unattainable woman with deep admiration. However, Shakespeare did something different: the first 126 of his sonnets are actually addressed to a young man. This was unusual for his time.
Shakespeare’s sonnets are now some of the most famous poems in English, and “Sonnet 18” is perhaps the most well-known of all. Interestingly, during Shakespeare’s life, these poems weren’t very popular and were mostly forgotten until 1780 when a man named Edmund Malone published them again. He suggested that they might reflect Shakespeare’s own life, which started new discussions about their meaning.
In Shakespeare’s group of sonnets, “Sonnet 18” is very important. The first 17 sonnets encourage the young man to have children to keep his beauty alive. For example, in Sonnet 12, Shakespeare writes that nothing can fight against time except for having children. But in Sonnet 18, Shakespeare makes a big change in his message: instead of saying that having kids is the best way to keep the young man’s beauty, he argues that poetry itself can do that. By saying this, he gives poetry a special power and makes it more important than he had suggested just a couple of poems before.
FAQ
What is the main theme of Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18?
Why does the poet compare his friend to a summer’s day?
How does the poet suggest that his friend’s beauty will last forever?
What literary devices does Shakespeare use in Sonnet 18?
What message does the poet want to convey about friendship?
Our other blog posts:
Critical Analysis of the novel “Things Fall Apart”
Critical Analysis of the novel “The Shadow Lines”
Critical Analysis of the novel “The Woman in White”
Critical Analysis of the novel “The Hound of Baskervilles”
Detailed summary of the novel “The Color Purple”
Detailed summary of the novel “Things Fall Apart”
Detailed summary of the novel “The Shadow Lines”
Detailed summary of the novel “The Woman in White”
Detailed summary of the novel “The Hound of Baskervilles”
Q&A of the novel “Things Fall Apart”
Q&A of the novel “The Shadow Lines”
Q&A of the novel “The Woman in White”
Q&A of the novel “The Hound of Baskervilles”
Q&A of the short story “The Yellow Wallpaper”
Critical Analysis of the literary terms “Allegory”
Critical Analysis of the literary terms “Alliteration”
Critical Analysis of the short story “The Yellow Wallpaper”
Critical Analysis of the poem “Kubla Khan”
Critical Analysis of the poem “Paradise Lost”
Critical Analysis of the poem “My Last Duchess”
Critical Analysis of the poem “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard”
Critical Analysis of the poem “Second Coming”
Critical Analysis of the poem “Dover Beach”
Other literary devices:
5 Timeless Beauty in Shakespeares Summers Day is an extraordinary analysis of the poem “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day“.
